Why I Needed an Insurance Bad Faith Lawyer
In early 2025, I found myself in a frustrating situation. My insurance company had delayed my claim for months, ignored my emails, and kept asking for the same paperwork over and over.
It wasn’t a small claim either — my home suffered water damage from a burst pipe, and repairs were going to cost over $25,000. I had done everything right: paid premiums on time, filed the claim promptly, and provided all requested documents.
Yet, the insurance company’s response was always vague: “We’re still reviewing your file.”
After nearly six months of waiting, I realized something was wrong. That’s when I learned about the term “insurance bad faith.”
What “Bad Faith” in Insurance Really Means
Insurance bad faith happens when an insurance company deliberately avoids paying a legitimate claim or fails to handle it fairly.
Common Examples of Insurance Bad Faith
- Denying a valid claim without proper reason
- Unreasonable delays in processing
- Offering a very low settlement compared to damages
- Misrepresenting policy terms
Signs Your Insurance Company May Be Acting in Bad Faith
- Repeated requests for unnecessary documents
- Sudden policy changes after a claim is filed
- Lack of communication or unexplained silence
In my case, I had multiple red flags — delays, lack of explanation, and lowball offers.
Read Also : Allstate Renters Insurance Quote 2025 – Don’t pay before read this article
How I Realized I Needed Legal Help
One night, after yet another “we’re still reviewing” email, I searched online for help and stumbled upon stories of people winning cases against insurance companies through insurance bad faith lawyers.
It clicked: I didn’t just have a slow claim; I had a possible bad faith case.
Finding the Right Insurance Bad Faith Lawyer
Research and Referrals
I started by asking friends and colleagues if they knew any lawyers who specialized in insurance disputes. I also searched Google for “insurance bad faith lawyer near me” and found several options.
Checking Reviews and Case Histories
I checked Google Reviews, Avvo, and even the state bar website to see each lawyer’s success rate and complaints filed against them.
Asking the Right Questions in the First Consultation
I learned to ask:
- Have you handled cases similar to mine?
- What were the outcomes?
- How do you charge clients in bad faith cases?
My First Meeting With the Lawyer — What Happened
In our first meeting, my lawyer reviewed my insurance policy, claim emails, and photos of the damage.
His verdict: I had a strong case for bad faith because:
- The insurance company had no valid reason for the delay.
- They had failed to respond within legally required timelines.
- Their settlement offer was less than 20% of the actual repair costs.
He explained that in many states, if a bad faith claim is proven, the insurance company may have to pay:
- The full claim amount
- Attorney’s fees
- Possible punitive damages
The Cost of Hiring an Insurance Bad Faith Lawyer
Contingency Fee Agreements
I was relieved to learn that most bad faith lawyers work on contingency — meaning they only get paid if you win. My lawyer’s rate was 33% of the settlement.
Hourly Rates vs. Flat Fees
Some lawyers charge $200–$500 per hour, but for bad faith cases, contingency is most common. This made it financially possible for me to proceed without paying upfront.
How My Lawyer Built My Case
Gathering Evidence
He collected:
- All emails with the insurance company
- My claim documents
- Damage repair estimates
- Expert witness statements
Communicating With the Insurance Company
Once he officially took over, communication shifted entirely to his office. The tone of the insurer’s replies changed immediately.
Negotiating for a Fair Settlement
Within three months, my lawyer had secured a settlement that covered my full repair costs plus additional compensation for the delay.
The Outcome of My Case and How It Changed My View on Insurance
The case settled for $40,000, which covered all damages and legal fees.
Before this experience, I believed insurance companies were always on the customer’s side. Now, I know they often act in their own best interest until challenged.
Lessons I Learned From the Experience
- Document everything from the start of your claim.
- Don’t wait too long to get legal help.
- Specialized lawyers matter — a general attorney may not know bad faith laws.
- Know your state’s deadlines for filing bad faith claims.
FAQs About Insurance Bad Faith Lawyers
1. How do I know if I have a bad faith case?
If your insurer delays, denies, or underpays your legitimate claim without reason, you might have one.
2. Will hiring a lawyer make my insurance company mad?
Possibly, but it also makes them take your claim seriously.
3. How long do bad faith cases take?
Anywhere from a few months to over a year, depending on complexity.
4. Do I need to pay upfront?
Most work on contingency, so you pay nothing unless you win.
5. Can I sue for emotional distress?
In some states, yes — if the insurer’s actions caused significant hardship.
6. Can a lawyer help even if I already accepted a settlement?
Sometimes, but it’s harder. Always consult a lawyer before accepting.
My Final Verdict: Should You Hire One?
From my experience — absolutely yes if you suspect bad faith. Without my lawyer, I might have accepted a settlement that didn’t even cover half my damages.
If you feel your insurance company isn’t playing fair, a specialized insurance bad faith lawyer can be the difference between walking away with nothing and getting what you’re owed.
